Historic recipe from Malinda Russell's 1866 cookbook "A Domestic Cook Book". Page 37. One of the earliest known cookbooks by an African American author.
Long, gentle boiling of collagen-rich calf head converts tough connective tissue into gelatin through hydrolysis, creating a naturally thick, silky broth without additional thickeners. The bones release minerals and marrow compounds that enhance flavor complexity. Finishing the brains with butter and eggs creates a custard-like texture through gentle protein coagulation, while stewing the tongue "dry" concentrates flavors through reduction and allows surface browning.
Before You Begin
•This is a historic recipe requiring sourcing from specialty butchers or ethnic markets; order the calf head at least one week in advance and request it be cleaned and split
•Read the entire recipe carefully—this involves processing multiple parts of the head into different preparations (soup, hash, brain custard, and tongue), requiring simultaneous timing
•Use a very large stockpot (at least 12 quarts) as the calf head needs to be fully submerged in water for even cooking
•Have separate bowls ready for sorting the different meat portions after boiling, as you'll work with upper head meat, lower jaw meat, brains, and tongue separately
•
Community Notes
0 notes
Sign in to share your thoughts and connect with the community
Modern cooks should note that quantities are vague in this 1866 recipe; expect to season assertively and adjust consistency to taste
•Be prepared for unfamiliar textures and a time-intensive process—this is advanced historical cooking, not a weeknight meal
Key Equipment
12-quart or larger stockpot with lidLarge slotted spoon or spider skimmer for removing head from brothChef's knife and cutting board dedicated to meat preparationFine-mesh strainer for brothMedium oven-safe baking dish for brain preparationMedium saucepan for stewing tongueMixing bowl for egg and brain mixture
Ingredients
Instructions
1
Dress the head and boil until done, remove the bones from the meat, take all the meat from the upper part of the head and chop fine, and put it into the soup, with chopped potatoes and carrots, chives, pepper, salt, parsley, sweet margery, and a little butter.
2
Stir a little flour and milk together to thicken the soup.
3
Make a hash of the meat from the under jaw.
4
Take the brains from the head, beat up eggs as for an omelet, turn this over the brains after seasoning with salt and pepper.
5
Melt some butter and turn on.
6
Set it in the oven to cook slowly.
Make Ahead
The calf head can be boiled up to 2 days ahead; cool the meat in the broth, then refrigerate together. The congealed fat can be easily removed from the surface. Remove bones and portion the meat when cold for easier handling. The tongue can be skinned and sliced 1 day ahead and refrigerated. Reheat components separately before final assembly.
Storage
Store the soup in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. The high gelatin content means it will solidify when cold—this is normal. Reheat gently on the stovetop, adding water or stock if needed to adjust consistency. Brain custard and tongue preparations should be consumed within 24 hours and are not recommended for freezing. The soup base (without brain custard) can be frozen for up to 3 months.
7
Skin and slice the tongue; put into a saucepan, with butter, pepper, and salt.
